|

When President Bush began his second term, he indicated a strong
interest in reforming the nation’s secondary schools to ensure that every
high school student graduates with proficiencies that will enable them to
succeed. The undersigned organizations support the President’s vision, and
ask that he also commit to reforms that will improve the well-being of
America’s youth, in particular
those who are the most vulnerable and
disconnected.
This memo outlines a series of recommendations, many of which can be
implemented within existing statutory and budget authority, to help the
nation’s most valuable resource—our youth—develop into successful,
self-sufficient adults. Nevertheless, we also recognize that many of the
federal programs that support the transition of disadvantaged youth to
productive adulthood are inadequately funded, leaving many eligible and
needy youth unable to access the services, education, and supports
requisite to successful transition.
According to the
White House Task Force for Disadvantaged Youth (April
2003), the National Academy of Sciences estimates that one-quarter of the
adolescents in this country are at serious risk of not achieving
productive adulthood. Nationally,
3 out of 10 young people who enter
public high school do not graduate four years later. The graduation rate
is only
50% for Hispanic, African American, and Native American youth.
This situation is especially devastating in the very poorest urban and
rural communities and school districts
Far too many young people are in danger of being left behind. Many
of these young people are already in the public’s care—in the foster care
and/or the
juvenile justice systems.
Over time, secondary school reform and innovation should transform the
landscape of education delivery. Until then, each year more than a
half-million youth will leave school without a high school diploma, the
necessary skills to compete in the labor market, or the community supports
they need to constructively engage with mainstream America. They will join
the approximately 5.4 million youth between the ages of 16 and 24 who are out of school and are faring poorly in the labor market and in their
communities.
Contrary to public perception, most of these youth desperately want to be
productive, and aspire to a better life.
As a country we have the knowledge and the technology to close the skills
gap and racial disparities that have persisted for far too long. It takes
political leadership, effective policies, and smart investments in our
young people to harness their energy and empower them with the
competencies to contribute to our economic engine.
Our country cannot afford to allow so many youth to linger outside the
mainstream economy, without the skills and supports they need to succeed.
Effective reform must include expanding the boundaries of the traditional
education system to engage communities, parents, employers, and other
sectors in developing effective pathways and supports to help students
remain in school and, just as important, reconnect those who have dropped
out but need a second chance.
The President has made clear his commitment to leave no child behind. As
he turns his attention to our high schools, he can send a powerful message
that he has high expectations for every student. He can command attention
from all levels of government and from American families, faith- and
community-based organizations, and employers to extend their stewardship
to find effective community-based solutions to this most pressing problem.
Our coalition of organizations stands ready, willing, and able to work
with the President to help all young people reach their full potential. We
ask for the President’s consideration and support for the following
recommendations.
-
Use the Presidential “bully pulpit” to set a national goal to Reach Out
and Reconnect our youth
-
Establish an interagency Federal Youth Development Council, as recommended
by the White House Task Force Report for Disadvantaged Youth
-
Improve youth services through better public
accountability
-
Establish flexibility in public education funds for disadvantaged youth,
to enable enrollment in the most appropriate educational environments
-
Use the reauthorization of key federal programs to strengthen supports for
youth transitioning to adulthood.
-
Expand opportunities for youth to engage in community service and work
experience
-
Provide incentives and technical support to increase employer
participation in developing internships, pipelines and intermediaries
|
|
|
Use the presidential “bully pulpit” to establish a goal to Reach Out and Reconnect our youth
By setting goals for reforming the American high schools, President Bush
can send a clear message that our nation is committed to providing
opportunity and support for all young people who want to constructively engage in their communities, better their academic skills, and be part
of a skilled workforce. The President can ask for the active participation of governors, municipal leaders, business leaders,
community and faith-based-organizations, and citizens in making sure our high schools are equipped to serve struggling students and our
communities stand ready to re-engage students who need another chance to get on track. |
|
|
Establish a Federal Youth Development Council
The White House Task Force Report on Disadvantaged Youth
found
fragmentation among the various federal youth funding streams and in
service delivery for disadvantaged youth. Lack of coordination among the
Departments of Labor, Education, Health and Human Services and the
Justice Department—all of which have programs and policies that serve
disadvantaged youth—makes it difficult for state and local programs to
blend funding streams and organize service delivery at the community
level. There are built-in disincentives for local coordination in the
regulations and policies set by the federal departments, and the work of
sorting them out at the state and local level is difficult. A Federal
Youth Development Council, that brings together the agency Secretaries,
representatives from the youth services field, employers,
representatives from local government, and youth can serve to:
- Keep attention focused on the issues of disadvantaged and disconnected
youth, set national priorities, measure progress on key indicators, and
make policy recommendations to the White House
- Establish specific task forces or advisory committees, which include
meaningful youth representation, to focus on the most pressing issues
(in particular, systemic issues and policies that contribute to
disparate outcomes for youth in certain subgroups) and foster
cross-sector participation in advancing solutions
- Facilitate ongoing federal inter-departmental collaboration and
inter-agency responses to relax the federal bureaucracy and promote the
flexibility needed for more responsive solutions
- Provide interagency support for state and local government efforts to
assess youth-related policies, programs, funding streams, indicators,
and data in order to create and implement strategic plans for
coordinated investment of federal, state, and local dollars to improve
outcomes for youth
The Federal Youth Coordination Act (H.R. 856/S. 409) was introduced in
the 109th Congress by Rep. Tom Osborne (R-NE) and Sen. Norm Coleman
(R-MN). Original co-sponsors include Senators Lamar Alexander (R-TN),
Mike DeWine (R-OH), and Representatives Harold Ford (D-TN), Pete
Hoekstra (R-MI), and Donald Payne (D-NJ).
|
|
|
Improve youth services through better public accountability
Requiring high schools, foster care and juvenile justice agencies, and
other federally funded agencies serving disadvantaged youth to publicly
report their demographics, service levels, expenditures and outcomes
would enable local communities to assess the magnitude of the problem,
system performance and who is—and is not—effectively served, and monitor
improvement over time. We recommend the following:
-
Develop a uniform definition for measuring graduation and drop-out
rates for local high schools, alternative schools, charter schools,
school districts, and states. Establish accountability measures under
the No Child Left Behind Act related to graduation rates and hold states
and local systems accountable for making progress towards those
benchmarks for all youth.
- Require states to monitor policies and practice that result in youth
being “pushed out” or disproportionately tracked to inappropriate
educational alternatives
-
Require HHS to implement the National Youth in Transition Data System
(the accountability system for the John H. Chafee Foster Care
Independence Program as mandated by the Foster Care Independence Act of
1999)
- Provide both incentives and sanctions to state and local
child welfare
and
juvenile justice systems to ensure effective transitional services,
including the requirement that at key risk points and before a youth is
discharged, there are explicit transition plans to connect youth to key
education, training, housing, and support services
-
Continue to support the Runaway, Homeless, and Missing Children
Protection Act of 2003, including the provision requiring HHS to
coordinate with the U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness to develop
a Report on Strategies to End Youth Homelessness.
|
|
|
Establish flexibility in federal public education funds for
disadvantaged youth, to enable enrollment in the most appropriate
education environments
High schools must be reconfigured to inspire and retain students,
support those who are struggling , remove the barriers to re-enrollment
for youth who have dropped out, and create non-traditional alternatives
for youth who can benefit from and choose to enroll in smaller, more
supportive environments. Students who drop out can often be re-engaged
and better served in alternative settings, like community-based academic
and experiential learning programs with a demonstrated ability to
achieve high school certification for these youth. Introducing
accountability and flexibility in financing alternative education
opportunities for older youth can allow more communities to work with
their local districts to develop alternate pathways to labor market
success for out-of-school youth.
- Provide incentives and technical assistance to enable public education
funds (federal, state, and local) to be directed to bona fide education
programs operated by qualified community-based organizations, community
colleges and other entities that are better suited to serve the complex
education, training, and support needs of youth seeking to reattach at
the secondary level
- Strengthen the capacity of the Department of Labor (in conjunction
with the Department of Education) to focus on community-based
alternative education strategies with special attention to effective
instructional technologies, delivery methods, workforce connections, and
performance accountability
- Invest in a knowledge development effort to identify the type of
instructional technologies and interventions that work for youth with
low literacy levels, and facilitate the expansion of such programs
- Synchronize the performance expectations for youth served by the adult
education system and the Workforce Investment Act system to remove the
disincentives to blending funding in the service of youth with extremely
low literacy levels
|
|
Use the reauthorization process to strengthen systems to support youth,
especially those at risk, in successfully transitioning to productive
adulthood
There are many key federal programs that support the transition of youth
to productive adulthood. The recommendations offered below
would improve these programs, and better enable the productive
engagement of our nation’s youth and a skilled workforce for employers.
|
|
Higher Education Act. Strengthen the ability of the community college
system to serve as a bridge for out-of-school youth seeking to gain
marketable skills and academic skills for success in post-secondary
education. There are promising community college-based models that allow
drop-outs to accrue credits towards high school and post secondary
credentialing, sometimes concurrently.
- Strengthen the ability of the TRIO programs to provide college
preparatory assistance to disadvantaged high school students and
out-of-school youth enrolled in alternative community-based programs
- Open access to higher education funding for high school drop-outs who
can demonstrate the ability to benefit from post-secondary education and
training; expand the definition of “ability to benefit,” as proposed by
the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators, to
include individuals without a high school diploma who have successfully
completed six units of college courses
- Adopt alternative measures for determining institutional eligibility
for student aid that do not discourage the enrollment of disadvantaged
or higher-risk youth, rather than relying solely on student loan default
rates
- Increase the amount of the maximum Pell Grant and direct the
Department of Education to maintain the current formula for calculating
eligibility so that hundreds of thousands of low-income young people
will not be denied access to a higher education
|
|
|
Workforce Investment Act
(H.R. 27 & S. 9). Reauthorize the WIA youth
title to serve as an effective transition support system for
out-of-school and extremely vulnerable youth. The WIA youth title
already requires the provision of case management and follow-up for
enrolled youth.
Requiring an increased focus on youth who are out of
school, homeless, or transitioning from foster care and the justice
system can provide the necessary community infrastructure to facilitate
their transition. Several other adjustments must be made to accommodate
the complex needs of these youth:
- Retain the requirement for Youth Councils under WIA and encourage and
enable the participation of the education and child welfare systems,
runaway and homeless youth grantees, and the justice system in
structuring the transition supports for vulnerable youth.
- Adjust the factors of the funding formula to ensure that the resources
target communities with the greatest level of youth distress and promote
increased expenditures per youth to reflect the need for more
comprehensive education, training, and transition support
- Implement policies that facilitate the sharing of information on
individual youth to enable better case management and outcomes tracking
across systems
- Build on the capacity developed in communities that were part of the
Youth Opportunities and the Young Offender demonstrations; use
discretionary funding to sustain efforts in communities where successful
systems innovation has occurred, which can serve as learning
laboratories for the rest of the system
- Recalibrate performance measures to take into account the increased
risk factors so that they don't serve as a disincentive to engaging the
youth with greatest needs
|
|
Temporary Assistance for Needy Families
(H.R. 1160 & S. 667).
Reauthorization provides the opportunity to refocus policy related to
youth in TANF households, young parents on TANF, and TANF’s role in
positive youth development. Specific recommendations include:
- Make explicit to states that expenditures of TANF funds on programs
that reconnect out-of-school youth to high quality education and
training alternatives is in keeping with national priorities
- Encourage the connection of young parents to post-secondary vocational
training and remove the disincentives inherent in the definitions of
work activity and the start of the TANF time clock
- For youth in TANF households who are drop-outs or at imminent risk of
dropping out, require that the Individual Responsibility Plans identify
specific steps to reconnecting them to education and training support
|
|
|
Serious and Violent Offenders Reentry Initiative.
The Second Chance Act of 2005
(H.R. 1704), introduced in the 109th Congress, would
reauthorize the Serious Violent and Offenders Reentry Initiative. We
encourage the Administration to support the following provisions:
- Support the provision to reauthorize the juvenile offender reentry
demonstration grant. With 100,000 youth exiting juvenile corrections
facilities each year, it is critical to aid their successful
reintegration into society through an array of services
- Support the provision that requires HHS to review the role of child
protective services after arrest and establish services to preserve
families
- Support the provisions authorizing mentoring grants to community-based
organizations and the Federal Resource Center for Children of Prisoners
|
|
|
The Carl D. Perkins Vocational and Technical Education Act
(H.R. 366 &
S. 250). In reauthorizing the Perkins Act, the Administration can urge
Congress to maintain the federal commitment to strengthening secondary
career and technical education opportunities. We recommend the
following:
- Make career preparation and technical education available to all
secondary school students, including those in alternative school
environments
- Improve the integration of learning for academic excellence through
the context of careers
- Expand strategies, such as work-based learning, experiential learning,
internships, career exploration, etc. for youth going to postsecondary
education or training or the workforce after high school
- Improve the rigor and quality of career and technical education by
ensuring a link to academic standards
- Align career and technical education curriculum to post-secondary
entrance requirements
|
|
Expand youth opportunities to engage in community service and work
experience
Teen employment is at its lowest rate since 1948. Economically
distressed communities face serious challenges in their ability to offer
young people the opportunities for gainful employment or civic
engagement that are key to preparing them for a productive adulthood.
The
White House Task Force for Disadvantaged Youth (October 2003)
recommended a youth service initiative that would allow older youth to
“display leadership by providing opportunities for them to serve
children living in high poverty areas of the United States.” Such
experiences enable youth to give back to their communities and develop
civic pride and leadership skills. They also provide an avenue for
communities to engage youth in the community building process. We
applaud the Administration’s expansion of AmeriCorps (administered by
the Corporation for National and Community Service), and ask that the
Administration increase its efforts to identify and support programs
through
AmeriCorps—such as
Service and Conservation Corps and YouthBuild—that
enroll youth who are low-income and/or out of school. In addition, much
can be achieved by focusing the investment in Learn and Serve America
on
successful and innovative programs and promoting systemic change that
leads to the infusion of service-learning throughout our nation’s
schools, colleges, and community-and faith-based organizations.
|
|
Provide incentives and technical support to increase employer
participation in developing internships, pipelines and intermediaries
The high-paying jobs and careers of the future will require levels of
education, skill, and technical competence that far exceed those typical
of youth coming from distressed communities and school systems. These
youth are the least likely to be exposed to exciting new career
opportunities in science, medicine, the arts, and other professions.
Expanding their horizons and aspirations can only be accomplished by
engaging the corporate sector to help young people explore workplaces
and understand the demands, rewards and prerequisites for entry. The
Bush administration can assist in the following ways:
Encourage federal contractors operating in distressed communities to engage with local intermediaries in providing internships and learning opportunities for disadvantaged youth
Through grants and technical assistance, expand the capacity of local intermediaries to work with business, the community and school systems to create pipelines and work opportunities
Support training and technical assistance to expand employers’ capacity to better manage diversity, serve as mentors, and constructively engage in the process of preparing youth for success in the economy of the future
The President has the opportunity to fulfill America’s promise to the millions of youth who, with additional support, can make a significant contribution to our economic and social well-being. The undersigned organizations look forward to working with this Administration using our collective ability to Reach out and Reconnect our youth to a vibrant future of physical, emotional, and economic well-being.
Acknowledgements
Thanks to the following
individuals for their contributions to this site:
Tim
Briceland-Betts, David Brown, Brandon Bruce, Thaddeus Ferber, Heather
Ford, Jodie Levin-Epstien, Linda Harris, Daniel Luzer, Robin Nixon, Angela Parker, Sally Prouty,
Jan Richter, Miriam Rollins, Gene Sofer, Dorothy Stoneman, David Taylor,
Mala Thakur.
|
|